Blue Jays vs. Orioles Series Betting Pick, DFS Plays – May 12

Submitted by Dan Shapiro on

Written by :

Dan Shapiro

Published on :

Gambling911.com has your Blue Jays vs. Orioles series betting pick and DFS plays for Tuesday May 12. 

Series: Blue Jays vs. Orioles

Pitching:

This one could be a bloodbath for Toronto’s Mark Buehrie as he has allowed the current Orioles roster to hit 70-for-203 off of him.  He’s also permitted 11 or more runs in two of his last starts (Buehrie picked up a win in his last start). 

Sure he had two quality starts against the Orioles this season already but Buehrie also gave up 8 hits in each of those.  Both times he lasted 6 innings. 

Baltimore’s Chris Tillman has given up 7 runs in his two starts vs. Toronto this season.  He gave up 10 hits his last start going up against the Yankees.

Note that four of the last six in this series heading into Monday had gone OVER 10 with another total hitting 8.  Monday night’s game did not go OVER 7 but that was to be expected based on the starting pitching.

We love that this game opened with a total of 8.5 and has since moved to 9 with books appearing to be encouraging gamblers to bet the UNDER.  We like the OVER 9 in this one.

There are plenty of daily fantasy MLB plays to consider this day from this matchup alone.

Right Fielder:

Jose Bautista – Following a sluggish start, Bautista has hit in eight of his last ten games and is 8-for-30 against Tillman with 5 RBIs and two homers.

Travis Snider has hit one time each in seven of his last ten games with one homer.  He’s priced at $2300.  He’s 5-for-9 against Buehrie.  The odds are good he’ll have at least a single against him in this game. 

3rd Base:

Josh Donaldson is 5-for-13 vs. Tillman.

Catcher:

Caleb Joseph does have 5 RBIs over his last 10 games with nine hits.  He entered Sunday’s game with an impressive .311 batting average and .907 OPS for the season but failed to have any hits.  He’s 4-for-8 with a homerun against Buehrie. 

1st Base:

Kevin Pillar – True he hasn’t gotten a hit in three days but is due and goes up against the man who has allowed him 3 hits on 7 at bats including a homerun.   He’s priced at $2600 coming into this game.

- Dan Shapiro, Gambling911.com

Related Content

Baseball in glove

Mariners vs. Rangers Home Run Prop Bets: Dominic Canzone, Joc Pederson, Luke Raley

The Mariners are listed as a -139 favorite, Rangers +114; over/under is 8 runs in this early Monday afternoon game.
Royals vs. Tigers Betting Preview July 24, 2026

Royals vs. Tigers Betting Preview July 24, 2026

The Royals vs. Tigers game Friday evening was seeing close to $1 million in betting volume at some prediction markets, making it among the most wagered on MLB games this day.
<iframe width="560" height="315" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/j5V5J1tnJJk?si=40gMzeXgFIIsO01y" title="YouTube video player" frameborder="0" allow="accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture; web-share" referrerpolicy="strict-origin-when-cross-origin" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Baseball Betting Solution for Bookies

AcePerHead.com offers a fully managed Pay Per Head (PPH) sportsbook software that allows bookies and agents to offer comprehensive MLB and baseball betting markets, not just cookie cutter money lines and totals you will find with some PPH providers.
Padres vs. Braves Betting Preview July 23, 2026

Padres vs. Braves Betting Preview July 23, 2026

The San Diego Padres play Game 4 of their series in Atlanta against the Braves Thursday. Pay Per Head baseball platforms feature a wide array of team and player prop bets for this game as well.