Yankees vs. Blue Jays Series Betting Picks, DFS Plays for May 4 thru 6

Submitted by Dan Shapiro on

Written by :

Dan Shapiro

Published on :

Gambling911.com has your Yankees vs. Blue Jays series betting picks and daily fantasy sports plays for May 4 through 6. 

The Series Overall: This series has been split overall with neither club having any advantage.  Seven of the last nine games in the series have gone UNDER 7.5, making Monday May 4 UNDER 9 especially enticing as one of our Monday free picks.

May 4 - The Starting Pitchers: Yankees RH Chase Whitley (1-0, 1.80 ERA) vs. Blue Jays RH R.A. Dickey (0-3, 5.23)

The 25-year-old Whitley surrendered one run and six hits while striking out five in his season debut last Tuesday.  He did not fare well against Toronto last season, giving up 13 runs and 19 hits in a total of nine innings pitched during two starts.   His last five games pitching five or more innings in 2015 resulted in no more than 2 runs per game.

Dioner Navarro poses the biggest threat to Whitley as he has gone 4-for-6 against him, however, lucky for Whitley, Navarro currently sits on the DL.

Dickey made his season debut at New York on April 8 and allowed one run on four hits and three walks in 6 1/3 innings without factoring in the decision.

May 4 – DFS Picks:  Alex Rodriguez would make for a pretty reliable roster pick Monday priced around $3600.   He has gone 8-for-24 against Dickey with 2 doubles and 2 RBIs along with a homerun. 

May 5 - The Starting Pitchers:  Yankees Michael Pineda vs. Blue Jays Marco Estrada. 

Pineda has allowed no fewer than 5 hits in his first five starts of the season.  The Yankees have not permitted more than 5 runs in any of those starts either.

Estrada will join the rotation for this game. 

May 4 – DFS Picks: NA

- Dan Shapiro, Gambling911.com

Related Content

Pope Leo XIV Chicago White Sox Prop Bets: Will He Attend a Game, Mentions, More

Pope Leo XIV Chicago White Sox Prop Bets: Will He Attend a Game, Mentions, More

The Pope pays out $300 for every $100 bet should he attend one of the White Sox games.
MLB Division Series and Game 1 Odds 2026

MLB Division Series and Game 1 Odds 2026

Three of the four Wild Card series wrapped up in two games, while the Braves and Phillies will play their rubber match this evening to see which team advances to the NLDS.
Seattle Mariners Next Manager Torey Lovullo Odds

Seattle Mariners Next Manager Torey Lovullo Odds

Lovullo promises a payout of $300 for every $100 bet.
Wild Card Series, Game 1 Lines and Updated World Series Odds 2026

Wild Card Series, Game 1 Lines and Updated World Series Odds 2026

It came down to the final day of the regular season for one team, but we now have the full Wild Card postseason picture on our plates.