Poker Player Accused of Bludgeoning Both Parents Could be Found “Not Guilty” Says Attorney

Written by:
C Costigan
Published on:
Ernie Scherer III

The defense attorney for poker player Ernie Scherer III claims the case against his client is “weak”.

Closing arguments were heard in the Scherer III murder trial these past few days.  He is accused of brutally beating and stabbing to death his parents, Ernest Scherer Jr., 60, and Charlene Abendroth, 57, in their Castlewood Country Club home outside of San Jose, California, in March of 2008.  The case gained national attention when Gambling911.com was called upon by the Alameda Country Sherriff’s Department to help cover the story beyond California’s Bay Area in hopes of finding potential witnesses and those who knew Scherer III on the poker circuit.  He had not yet been charged with the crime. 

Scherer’s attorney, Richard Foxall,has even expressed concern over a glowing piece appearing in a local paper regarding outgoing Sergeant Scott Dudek – the man who led the investigation against his client  - and its potential impact on jurors.  

Foxall repeatedly informed the jury that  the prosecution has the burden to prove that Scherer is guilty of a double slaying,something he says they have failed to do.

"If you look long and hard at anyone's life you are going to find coincidences," Foxall said. "Almost nobody's life is subjected to the amount of scrutiny Mr. Scherer's life has been."

Scherer’s infidelity, lack of emotion and deceptiveness applied as a poker player were regular themes brought up during the trial. 

Nothing in the case can positively place Scherer at the gruesome scene of his parents killing, Foxall said, insisting there were explanations for each piece of evidence presented by the prosecution.

The case against the defendant hinges heavily on surveillance video of a car similar to Scherer III’s own arriving and leaving his parents home the day of the murders.    Prosecutor Mike Nieto also presented the jury with a receipt for a youth baseball bat reportedly used in the commission of the crime purchased across the street from where the defendant had bought gasoline just minutes prior.  Sneaker prints left at the scene match those of the Nike shoes that were bought along with the baseball bat.  The prosecution also sought to demonstrate that Scherer III purposely shut off his cell phone at the time of the murders to hide his location. 

"It's a chain and that chain is broken," Foxall said during his closing arguments. "Any coincidence that does not prove beyond a reasonable doubt is a chain that is broken."

Foxall concluded that his client was a victim of a witch hunt.

"The detectives became advocates for a certain outcome in this case," Foxall said.

- Christopher Costigan, Gambling911.com Publisher


Gambling911.com has been serving the gambling community with news around the clock since September 2000.

Follow us on Twitter for all the latest breaking gambling news

Follow us on Facebook.  Become a fan here.


Poker News

Easy poker games to play at home

Easy Poker Games to Play at Home

For centuries, poker games have been a source of fun.

Hellmuth Announces Big Match This Week Versus Tom Dwan

Hellmuth Announces Big Match This Week Versus Tom Dwan

A little bit of a teaser Monday night courtesy of Phil Hellmuth, who left his followers hanging with the tweet "Big news coming".

BetMGM Announces Premiere BetMGM Poker Championship

The $1M tournament is set to headline 2022 ARIA Poker Classic

$5 Million GTD Venom PKO Tournament Returns for May 2022

$5 Million GTD Venom PKO Tournament Returns for May 2022

This is the biggest Progressive Knockout Event in online poker and you can qualify to win a $2650 seat.

Daniel Cates Alludes to Decade Long Dispute With Tom Dwan in Light of Recent Cheating Claims

Daniel Cates Alludes to Decade Long Dispute With Tom Dwan in Light of Recent Cheating Claims

In recent weeks, there has been a spate of controversies surrounding the world of poker, mostly tied to alleged cheating scandals.  Now enter poker pros Daniel Cates and Tom "Durrrr" Dwan into the fray.