New York City vs Toronto FC Betting Odds, Goalscorer Prop Bets: Nicolas Fernandez, Benie Traore, Talles Magno

New York City FC will meet Toronto FC in a Major League  Soccer fixture at Yankee Stadium on August 1, 2026.

New York is the -160 favorite here while Toronto promises a nearly $400 payout for every $100 bet. 

Currently, New York City FC holds fifth position in the standings with 25 points, while Toronto FC sits in twelfth place accumulating 16 points over the campaign.

Form favors New York City FC given their recent run of four wins from their past six league outings, contrasting with Toronto FC’s struggles, recording four losses in their last six matches across all competitions.

Recent clashes have seen goals flowing freely, with New York City FC’s last three league matches featuring over 2.5 goals, and Toronto FC’s last six games seeing four go over that mark.

Popular goalscorer prop bets include Nicolas Fernandez paying $320 for every $100 bet to score the first goal, and Benie Traore, Talles Magno, Hannes Wolf and Seymour Reid each pay $550.  They all pay around $180 for every $100 bet to score an anytime goal, with the exception of Fernandez who is priced at -110 to do so. 

The goalscorer betting markets should be hot for this match. 

New York City FC have scored 2+ goals against Toronto FC in all of their last 4 home league matches.

Over 2.5 goals were seen in New York City FC's last 4 home matches against Toronto FC in Major League Soccer.

The team of Toronto FC have conceded an average of 1.82 goals in their matches in Major League Soccer.

First Goalscorer

Nicolas Fernandez
+320
Benie Traore
+550
Talles Magno
+550
Hannes Wolf
+550
Seymour Reid
+550
Malachi Jones
+700
Agustin Ojeda
+750
Josh Sargent
+750
Deandre Kerr
+800
Emilio Aristizabal
+1000
Djordje Mihailovic
+1000
Maximo Carrizo
+1100
Jules-Anthony Vilsaint
+1100
Daniel Salloi
+1200
Derrick Etienne
+1300
Andres Perea
+1400
No Goalscorer
+1500
Theo Corbeanu
+1500
Malik Henry
+1800
Markus Cimermancic
+2000
Jonathan Shore
+2200
Jonathan Osorio
+2200
Niklas Dorsch
+2200
Tayvon Gray
+2700
Raheem Edwards
+3500
Mitja Ilenic
+3500
Richie Laryea
+3500
Alonso Coello
+4000
James Sands
+4500
Walker Zimmerman
+4500
Kobe Franklin
+5000
Nico Cavallo
+5000
Benjamin Kuscevic
+6000
Thiago Martins
+6500
Zane Monlouis
+8000
Richard Chukwu
+8000

Anytime Goalscorer

Nicolas Fernandez
-110
Benie Traore
+170
Seymour Reid
+170
Hannes Wolf
+170
Talles Magno
+180
Malachi Jones
+230
Josh Sargent
+240
Agustin Ojeda
+250
Deandre Kerr
+260
Emilio Aristizabal
+330
Djordje Mihailovic
+350
Jules-Anthony Vilsaint
+360
Maximo Carrizo
+370
Daniel Salloi
+410
Derrick Etienne
+460
Theo Corbeanu
+500
Andres Perea
+500
Malik Henry
+600
Markus Cimermancic
+700
Niklas Dorsch
+750
Jonathan Shore
+800
Jonathan Osorio
+850
Tayvon Gray
+1000
Mitja Ilenic
+1300
Richie Laryea
+1500
Raheem Edwards
+1500
Alonso Coello
+1500
Walker Zimmerman
+1800
James Sands
+1900
Nico Cavallo
+2000
Kobe Franklin
+2000
Thiago Martins
+2500
Benjamin Kuscevic
+2500
Richard Chukwu
+3000
Zane Monlouis
+3300

• Dan Shapiro, Gambling911.com