Next Supreme Court Justice Odds Lists 18 Candidates

Submitted by Press Release on

Written by :

Press Release

Published on :

Andrew Oldham

Last week, it was confirmed that Justice Samuel Alito received medical attention after falling ill last month.

Alito is the Supreme Court's second-oldest member at 76. The news above has fueled speculation about Alito's retirement.

Justice Clarence Thomas is 77, and there are rumors that he could also step down this year.

Oddsmakers are now projecting who will be named as the next appointed Supreme Court Justice should either Alito or Thomas retire.

BetOnline.ag has made Andrew Oldham the favorite with 2/1 odds.

Aileen Cannon is second on the board at 4/1, while Amul Thapar, James Ho and Emil Bove all have better than 10/1 chances.

There are 18 candidates on the list below.

It’s also worth noting that Vegas believes there will be two new justices appointed before the next president is elected. Zero replacements is a longshot at 14/1.

Next Supreme Court Justice 
Andrew Oldham2/1
Aileen Cannon4/1
Amul Thapar7/1
James Ho8/1
Emil Bove8/1
Neomi Rao14/1
Patrick Burnatay16/1
Raymond Kethlege22/1
Mike Lee25/1
Lawrence VanDyke25/1
Michael Park25/1
Matthew Kacsmaryk28/1
Ted Cruz33/1
Barbara Lagoa33/1
Stuart Kyle Duncan33/1
Kathryn Mizelle33/1
Kenneth Lee50/1

How many new Justices appointed before 2028?

2 (-135)

1 (+120)

3+ (+800)

0 (+1400)

  • BetOnline Press 

Related Content

Top Gambling News Stories for Monday October 12, 2026

Top Gambling News Stories for Monday October 12, 2026

Top Trending: Chargers 0-5 - Jim Harbaugh First NFL Head Coach Fired Odds - Full Gambling Loss Tax Deduction Legislation - New York AI Gambling Proposal
Cleveland Guardians Payout Odds to Win 2026 ALCS

Cleveland Guardians Payout Odds to Win 2026 ALCS

The Cleveland Guardians are moving on after completing an 0-2 comeback against the Chicago White Sox, rattling off three consecutive wins to take the series.
2026 Week 6 NFL Betting Lines

2026 Week 6 NFL Betting Lines

NFL Week 6 is headlined by last year’s top seeds (Seattle/Denver) playing on Thursday Night Football.
Ravens vs. Falcons Total Passing Yards Prop Bets: Michael Penix Jr. vs. Tyler Huntley

Ravens vs. Falcons Total Passing Yards Prop Bets: Michael Penix Jr. vs. Tyler Huntley

Michael Penix Jr. is a big -260 favorite to have the most passing yards in this game while Tyler Huntley pays close to $200 for every $100 bet.