John Mateer New Favorite to Win Heisman Trophy 2025

Written by :

C Costigan

Published on :

1 September, 2025

Week 1 of the college football season is almost in the books, and we already have new CFP Championship and Heisman Trophy favorites at BetOnline.ag.

Texas lost to Ohio State yesterday, and Arch Manning didn’t exactly set the world ablaze.

Here are some notes on the changes after yesterday’s games:

Ohio State is the new favorite passing Texas, Georgia and Penn State.
Texas is now fourth at 15/2.
Alabama and Clemson went from 17/2 to 16/1 after their losses.

Update CFP Championship and Heisman odds can be found here and by scrolling below.

2025 CFP Championship
Ohio State	25/4	(+625)
Georgia	13/2	(+650)
Penn State	13/2	(+650)
Texas	15/2	(+750)
LSU	9/1
Notre Dame	9/1
Alabama	16/1
Clemson	16/1
Oregon	16/1
Miami Florida	20/1
Oklahoma	28/1
Florida	33/1
Michigan	33/1
Texas A&M	33/1
Auburn	35/1
Ole Miss	35/1
USC	50/1
Florida State	66/1
South Carolina	66/1
Georgia Tech	75/1
Tennessee	75/1
Louisville	80/1
SMU	100/1
Utah	100/1
Arizona State	125/1
Indiana	125/1
Texas Tech	125/1
Illinois	150/1
Missouri	150/1
TCU	175/1
Iowa	200/1
Iowa State	200/1
Washington	200/1
Nebraska	250/1
Baylor	300/1
Minnesota	300/1
Kansas	400/1
Arkansas	500/1
Michigan State	500/1
Pittsburgh	500/1
Tulane	500/1
Colorado	750/1
Duke	750/1
Kansas State	750/1
Air Force	1000/1
Appalachian State	1000/1
Arizona	1000/1
Arkansas State	1000/1
Army	1000/1
Ball State	1000/1
Boise State	1000/1
Boston College	1000/1
Bowling Green	1000/1
Buffalo	1000/1
BYU	1000/1
California	1000/1
Central Michigan	1000/1
Charlotte	1000/1
Cincinnati	1000/1
Coastal Carolina	1000/1
Colorado State	1000/1
Connecticut	1000/1
East Carolina	1000/1
Eastern Michigan	1000/1
FIU	1000/1
Florida Atlantic	1000/1
Fresno State	1000/1
Georgia Southern	1000/1
Georgia State	1000/1
Hawaii	1000/1
Houston	1000/1
Jacksonville State	1000/1
James Madison	1000/1
Kennesaw State	1000/1
Kent State	1000/1
Kentucky	1000/1
Liberty	1000/1
Louisiana	1000/1
Louisiana Tech	1000/1
Marshall	1000/1
Maryland	1000/1
Massachusetts	1000/1
Memphis	1000/1
Miami Ohio	1000/1
Middle Tennessee	1000/1
Mississippi State	1000/1
Navy	1000/1
NC State	1000/1
Nevada	1000/1
New Mexico	1000/1
New Mexico State	1000/1
North Carolina	1000/1
North Texas	1000/1
Northern Illinois	1000/1
Northwestern	1000/1
Ohio	1000/1
Oklahoma State	1000/1
Old Dominion	1000/1
Oregon State	1000/1
Purdue	1000/1
Rice	1000/1
Rutgers	1000/1
Sam Houston State	1000/1
San Diego State	1000/1
San Jose State	1000/1
South Alabama	1000/1
South Florida	1000/1
Southern Mississippi	1000/1
Stanford	1000/1
Syracuse	1000/1
Temple	1000/1
Texas State	1000/1
Toledo	1000/1
Troy	1000/1
Tulsa	1000/1
UAB	1000/1
UCF	1000/1
UCLA	1000/1
UL Monroe	1000/1
UNLV	1000/1
Utah State	1000/1
UTEP	1000/1
UTSA	1000/1
Vanderbilt	1000/1
Virginia	1000/1
Virginia Tech	1000/1
Wake Forest	1000/1
Washington State	1000/1
West Virginia	1000/1
Western Kentucky	1000/1
Western Michigan	1000/1
Wisconsin	1000/1
Wyoming	1000/1

2025 Heisman Trophy
John Mateer	7/1
Garrett Nussmeier	15/2	(+750)
Gunner Stockton	12/1
LaNorris Sellers	12/1
Cade Klubnik	14/1
Jeremiah Smith	14/1
Arch Manning	16/1
Dante Moore	16/1
Jeremiyah Love	16/1
Carson Beck	18/1
Drew Allar	18/1
Jackson Arnold	18/1
Sam Leavitt	20/1
Devon Dampier	22/1
DJ Lagway	22/1
Thomas Castellanos	25/1
Austin Simmons	33/1
Bryce Underwood	33/1
Julian Sayin	33/1
Marcel Reed	33/1
Ty Simpson	33/1
Kevin Jennings	35/1
CJ Carr	40/1
Beau Pribula	50/1
Haynes King	50/1
Jalon Daniels	50/1
Ryan Williams	50/1
Miller Moss	55/1
Avery Johnson	66/1
Demond Williams Jr	66/1
Fernando Mendoza	66/1
Jayden Maiava	66/1
Josh Hoover	66/1
Dylan Raiola	100/1
Sawyer Robertson	100/1
Eli Holstein	150/1
Kyron Drones	150/1
Nico Iamaleava	150/1
Steve Angeli	150/1