Twitter Survey Shows Which MLB Fans Complain About Calls the Most

Submitted by C Costigan on

Written by :

C Costigan

Published on :

Even though MLB umpires are calling ball and strikes at one of their best rates in years, fan complaints are at an all-time high.

In 2015, umps called 90.4% of balls and strikes accurately, per UmpScorecards. This season, that percentage is up to 93.5%, on par with last year's 93.6% rate.

But fans continue to whine, and Rob Manfred has said that "Robo-Umps" will likely be introduced in 2024.

With all that said, it got us wondering which MLB fans have complained the most in 2022. The Yankees? The Red Sox? The Dodgers?

Well, according to a data sweep conducted by BetOnline.ag, which used a trends software and Twitter API, St. Louis Cardinals fans tweet more complaints than any other fanbase.

umpire-complaining.png

This graphic below  is based on Twitter data since the start of the season. BetOnline tracked negative tweets from each MLB fanbase about "umpires."

For example, all tweets tagging or mentioning the Yankees, that also talk about umpires, and contain negative keywords such as cheat, cheating, horrible, awful, worst, screwed, paid, terrible, favoring, stupid, dumb, overturn, embarrassing, bad call, missed call, horrible call, terrible call, etc. This was then repeated for each team.

If you are able to use this information in your content, please consider citing the source, www.BetOnline.ag.

Here are the fanbase percentages (percent of all tweets that are negative tweets about umpires):

mlb-fan-complaints.png

St. Louis Cardinals – 6.89%

Washington Nationals – 6.67%

Los Angeles Angels – 6.48%

Chicago White Sox – 6.23%

Seattle Mariners – 6.07%

Houston Astros – 5.97%

Tampa Bay Rays – 5.63%

Miami Marlins – 5.26%

San Francisco Giants – 4.68%

Texas Rangers – 4.33%

Philadelphia Phillies – 4.23%

New York Yankees – 4.18%

Cincinnati Reds – 4.16%

Toronto Blue Jays – 4.10%

Atlanta Braves – 3.73%

Kansas City Royals – 3.43%

Pittsburgh Pirates – 2.95%

Oakland Athletics – 2.81%

New York Mets – 2.77%

Minnesota Twins – 2.74%

Baltimore Orioles – 2.62%

Milwaukee Brewers – 2.42%

Colorado Rockies – 1.75%

Boston Red Sox – 1.40%

Detroit Tigers – 1.33%

Chicago Cubs – 1.26%

San Diego Padres – 1.14%

Los Angeles Dodgers – 0.99%

Arizona Diamondbacks – 0.90%

Cleveland Guardians – 0.71%

Related Content

Falcons vs. Packers Total Rushing Yards Prop Bets: Bijan Robinson, Kaleb Johnson, MarShawn Lloyd

Falcons vs. Packers Total Rushing Yards Prop Bets: Bijan Robinson, Kaleb Johnson, MarShawn Lloyd

Bijan Robinson is the big -230 favorite to have the most rushing yards for Thursday's game between the Atlanta Falcons and Green Bay Packers.
James Talarico Now Priced at -185 to Win Against Ken Paxton in Texas Senate Race

James Talarico Now Priced at -185 to Win Against Ken Paxton in Texas Senate Race

This comes as a new Marist poll released on Sept. 23, 2026 shows Talarico leading 50% to 44%.
Florida Panthers Favorites to Win 2027 Stanley Cup With Payout of $800 on a $100 Bet

Florida Panthers Favorites to Win 2027 Stanley Cup With Payout of $800 on a $100 Bet

The Carolina Hurricanes begin their defense of the Stanley Cup this coming Tuesday by raising the championship banner against the Florida Panthers—the winners of the previous two Stanley Cups.

You Can Now Bet Which Week the LA Chargers Win a Game

You Can Now Bet Which Week the LA Chargers Win a Game

Every week throughout the season, we will have props via BetOnline Sports & Casino pertaining to the upcoming week’s games and pressing stories in the NFL.