New York Times: Daily Fantasy Sports and Hidden Costs of Weird U.S. Gambling Laws

Submitted by Don Shapiro on

Written by :

Don Shapiro

Published on :

The New York Times on Thursday discusses how some odd piece of legislation, the Unlawful Internet Gaming Enforcement Act, has helped to facility today’s boom in Daily Fantasy Sports, the very activity it was likely trying to prevent.

Online gambling diehards know the legislation well and by its abbreviated form UIGEA. 

That law, passed in October 0f 2006, was designed to prevent online gambling via bank transactions.  However, powerful lobbying groups such as representing Horse Racing, the state lotteries and fantasy sports managed to successfully push through an exception.

And there you have it with the later, Daily Fantasy Sports, or as some would call it, gambling via fantasy sports.   

An entire industry has emerged out of a legal loophole for something that looks a whole lot like sports gambling, writes Neil Irwin of the New York Times.

The very complexity and opacity that make daily fantasy sports legal also make it more likely that the casual fan will lose money. There is a truism in investing that complexity favors the big guy and disadvantages the little guy, and it applies here as well. If securities laws were like gambling laws, it would be illegal for people to buy shares of Google or a United States Treasury bond, because that would be gambling, but legal for them to invest in currency swaps that pay a return if the Swiss franc, Argentine peso and Vietnamese dong together outperform the Swedish krona, Mexican peso and South Korean won.

The fantasy sports industry argues that its service is not gambling at all, but rather a game of skill. It’s the sort of game specifically allowed by most state laws and by a 2006 federal law restricting online gambling that carved out protections for fantasy sports leagues. The industry is right about that much. It is a skill, and it unquestionably rewards those who apply dogged analytics to assembling their fantasy lineups.

Irwin suggests that, in some respect, Daily Fantasy Sports are the very worst form of gambling there is.

If you walk into a Las Vegas sports book and put money on a game in some sport you know nothing whatsoever about, you may not win, but you will almost certainly get fair odds relative to the risk you are taking. Playing daily fantasy sports, you will probably get your hat handed to you unless you deploy lots of computing power and analytical techniques that most of us don’t have the time, inclination or skill to use.

- Don Shapiro, Gambling911.com

Related Content

Total Passing Yards Prop Bets for CJ Carr vs. UNC

Total Passing Yards Prop Bets for CJ Carr vs. UNC

Carr's season totals are 67-of-95 for 963 yards, with a very strong 10.1 yards per attempt and 184.8 passer rating. He's also rushed for two touchdowns, giving him 11 total TDs through four games.
Michigan vs. Minnesota Total Rushing Yards Prop Bets: TJ Thomas, Jordan Marshall, Bryce Underwood

Michigan vs. Minnesota Total Rushing Yards Prop Bets: TJ Thomas, Jordan Marshall, Bryce Underwood

The leading rusher between the two teams is Minnesota's TJ Thomas. His over/under rushing yards total for this game was coming in at 28.5.
Alabama vs Mississippi State Total Receiving Yards Prop Bets: Anthony Evans, Ryan Coleman-Williams

Alabama vs Mississippi State Total Receiving Yards Prop Bets: Anthony Evans, Ryan Coleman-Williams

For No. 7 Alabama at No. 16 Mississippi State on Saturday at 12 pm EDT, the top receiving threats are Anthony Evans III for Mississippi State and Ryan Coleman-Williams for Alabama
Find Micah Gilbert Player Prop Bets vs. North Carolina

Find Micah Gilbert Player Prop Bets vs. North Carolina

Micah Gilbert has been one of Notre Dame's breakout players in 2026. Through four games, the junior wide receiver has 15 catches for 334 yards and two touchdowns, averaging a huge 22.3 yards per reception and 83.5 receiving yards per game.