Ifrah Law Wins Dismissal With Prejudice in PokerStars Illinois Class Actions

Submitted by Press Release on

Written by :

Press Release

Published on :

WASHINGTON — Ifrah Law PLLC, a Washington, D.C.-based law firm focused on complex civil and criminal litigation, won dismissals yesterday in two attempted class actions against PokerStars, the world’s largest publicly traded gaming company.

Judge David R. Herndon granted the motion to dismiss a second amended complaint filed by Kelly Sonneberg and Casey Sonnenberg, while simultaneously dismissing a companion claim brought by the same law firm by plaintiff Daniel and Judy Fahrner against PokerStars’ sister operator Full Tilt.

The dismissal in the plaintiff-friendly Southern District of Illinois ends the plaintiffs’ long-running attempts to exploit a centuries-old statute to form a class action of thousands—and potentially millions—of Illinois residents who allegedly held personal accounts with PokerStars.

“This is a major victory for PokerStars and instructive for other online gaming providers facing similar attacks from plaintiffs seeking unjust windfalls,” said Jeff Ifrah, the founder of Ifrah Law. “Through three amended filings by the plaintiffs—alleging many new claims—we clearly proved that the plaintiffs’ cases lacked any merit.”

In August 2012, Sonnenberg filed a class action suit in St. Clair County Circuit Court against Rational Entertainment, which operates PokerStars, as well as several of its executives and associated companies. Sonnenberg sought to recover gambling losses of PokerStars’ Illinois players under the Illinois Loss Recovery Act, which allows individuals to collect losses on behalf of third parties, provided those third parties fail to make their own claim within six months of losing the wager. Sonnenberg claimed to be related to someone who incurred a loss.

However, Illinois courts have held that the winner, and not the “keeper of the house,” is liable to the loser, unless the keeper of the house also risks money in the gambling activity (Holmes v. Brickey).

“In what is a traditionally plaintiff-friendly court, the judge agreed with all of our arguments—including the plaintiffs’ failures to specify a specific loss and to allege that either Full Tilt Poker or PokerStars, as the ‘house,’ could be considered winners within the meaning of the Illinois gambling-loss recovery statute,” Ifrah said.

Herndon also found that Sonnenberg had not sufficiently detailed a “loser” or a “loss.”

“Among many other points, the judge agreed with us that the addition of the affidavits from Daniel Fahrner and Casey Sonnenberg did not overcome the plaintiffs’ failures to allege when the losses occurred, to whom the losses were sustained, and what the loss amounts were,” Ifrah said.

“This was an incredibly high-stakes case,” said Ifrah Law attorney Rachel Hirsch. “As the Illinois Loss Recovery Act permits an award of triple the amount of losses, millions of dollars were at stake. This win will protect other online gaming providers from similar meritless actions.”

Ifrah Law lawyers Jeff Ifrah, David Deitch and Rachel Hirsch represented PokerStars and Rational FT. Bill Niehoff of Mathis, Marifian & Richter of Belleville, Illinois, served as local counsel on the matter.

The cases are Sonnenberg v. Scheinberg et al (3:13-cv-00344-DRH-SCW) and Fahrner v. Bitar et al (3:13-cv-00227-DRH-SCW) in the U.S. District Court of the Southern District of Illinois.

Related Content

Israel vs Austria Goalscorer Betting Markets - Sasa Kalajdzic, Michael Gregoritsch

Israel vs Austria Goalscorer Betting Markets - Sasa Kalajdzic, Michael Gregoritsch

Michael Gregoritsch pays out $130 for every $100 bet to score an anytime goal.
Denmark vs. Norway Goalscorer Betting Markets - Erling Haaland, Rasmus Højlund

Denmark vs. Norway Goalscorer Betting Markets - Erling Haaland, Rasmus Højlund

Denmark v Norway goalscorer betting markets feature the great Erling Braut Haaland at a pretty good price of -130.
Wales vs. Portugal Goalscorer Betting Picks: Gonçalo Ramos, João Félix Lead Anytime Scorer Odds

Wales vs. Portugal Goalscorer Betting Picks: Gonçalo Ramos, João Félix Lead Anytime Scorer Odds

Goalscorer betting markets for Tuesday's Wales v Portugal match include Gonçalo Ramos priced at around even odds to score an anytime goal.
Online Pokies Australia 2026: Real Money Games, RTPs and How to Pick Right

Online Pokies Australia 2026: Real Money Games, RTPs and How to Pick Right

Pokies have been baked into Australian leisure for decades. The online shift didn't change that; it just moved the reels to the phone. By mid-2026, the domestic iGaming market sits at over AUD 7 billion, with online pokies taking a growing cut.