Patent Suit Against Caesars Entertainment Corp, MGM Others Dismissed

Submitted by Gilbert Horowitz on

Written by :

Gilbert Horowitz

Published on :

Case 3:12-cv-00741-CWR-FKB Document 76 Filed 10/23/13: A patent infringement lawsuit filed by MGT Gaming late last year against MGM Resorts International, Caesars Entertainment Corporation, and Penn National Gaming, Inc. has been dismissed in a Mississippi District Court.  

Last year at this time, MGT was a company with only one operating unit, legacy medical technology business Medicsight, which the company has subsequently sold.  Today they are in the business of online and mobile gaming along with fantasy sports.

The initial lawsuit was filed in December of last year.  It contended that WMS Defendants and the Aruze Defendants alleging that they infringed United States Patent 7,892,088 (“the ‘088 patent”).  The ‘088 patent is “directed to a gaming system in which a second game played on an interactive sign is triggered once a specific event occurs in a first game, e.g., a slot machine.”  Docket No. 19 (“MGT Complaint”), at ¶ 7.  Plaintiff alleges that the “defendants either manufacture and sell gaming systems in violation of plaintiff’s patent rights or operate casinos that offer such gaming systems.”

More specifically, MGT asserted that the named defendants “have infringed and continue to infringe at least claims 1-3 and 6 of the ‘088 patent, either literally or under the doctrine of equivalents.”

The Defendants’ filed a Motion to Dismiss, and on Thursday, that motion was granted, “in part with respect to the claims of contributory and induced infringement and denied with respect to the claim of direct infringement.”

WMS Gaming and Aruze were also named as defendants.

Docket No. 38, MGT Resp. to WMS Gaming, at 22.  MGT also acknowledged on rebuttal that it did not have the necessary facts to establish a claim for Contributory infringement under 35 U.S.C. § 271(c) and agreed to remove that allegation from its pleadings until discovery produced facts that would allow it to make this claim.

Given these concessions, the claims for induced and contributory infringement were dismissed without prejudice.

The Plaintiff’s claims against Casino Defendants was stayed pending the outcome of the litigation against WMS and Aruze because the claims against the Casino Defendants are peripheral to this suit. 

- Gilbert Horowitz, Gambling911.com

Related Content

Sweepstakes Casino Review - Crown Coins Casino Praised for Fast Redemptions

Sweepstakes Casino Review - Crown Coins Casino Praised for Fast Redemptions

With the sweepstakes casino industry so volatile these days considering both the popularity of the sector and individual state efforts to quash it, Gambling911.com looks at both the positive and the negative reviews coming in for all brands.
VGW Launches New Chumba Casino iOS App

VGW Launches New Chumba Casino iOS App

VGW is pleased to announce Chumba Casino – the premier online social casino experience in the U.S. – has launched a new iOS app in the Apple App Store, giving players the brand’s full experience in a modern, state of the art native app.
Chumba Casino to Remain in Oklahoma Following Sweepstakes Casino Ban, Introduces Chumba Spins

Chumba Casino to Remain in Oklahoma Following Sweepstakes Casino Ban, Introduces Chumba Spins

Oklahoma's sweepstakes casino ban went into effect Sunday November 1.
Revisiting the So-Called 'Winna.com Casino Scam'

Revisiting the So-Called 'Winna.com Casino Scam'

The most recent TrustPilot reviews of Winna.com are especially head scratching. All are one star interspersed with a few five star reviews that tend to lack in substance.