PokerStars Parent Company Files Motion to Dismiss Domain Case

Submitted by Ace King on

Written by :

Ace King

Published on :

PokerStars parent company, the Rational Group, has filed a motion to dismiss in a 2008 case brought by the commonwealth of Kentucky to seize 141 online gambling domains.

BetOnline

OnlinePokerReport.com obtained a copy of the Motion to Dismiss.  They highlight four key aspects of the filing:

  1. Kentucky doesn’t have in rem jurisdiction over the PokerStars domain. Why? Because both the registrar of the domain and the registry of the domain extension are outside of Kentucky. And because Kentucky was never able to affect seizure or otherwise show control over the domain. More to the point, if the DoJ was able to seize the domain names while Kentucky had a claim on them, the DoJ’s ability to do so moots any claim by Kentucky to have control over the names.   
  2. Kentucky didn’t serve notice properly. As the motion puts it “The Commonwealth never provided REEL nor RIHL with notice, service, or an opportunity for a hearing” – and without doing so, the motion argues, you can’t seize property in relation to a civil action under Kentucky law.
  3. Domains aren’t gambling devices. This is the most interesting area of the case, for reasons we’ll discuss below. The issue was argued successfully in front of the Kentucky Court of Appeals, who concluded that domains were not gambling devices as part of their larger decision regarding the case. That appeals court decision was reversed by the Kentucky Supreme Court, but on separate grounds – the Supreme Court did not address the issue of domains as gambling devices in their reversal.
  4. Domain forfeiture would be unconstitutional. On both the federal and state level. Free speech, interference with interstate commerce, state sovereignty and property seizure without compensation.

The full Motion to Dismiss can be found on the OnlinePokerReport.com website here.

- Ace King, Gambling911.com

Related Content

Sweepstakes Casino Review - Crown Coins Casino Praised for Fast Redemptions

Sweepstakes Casino Review - Crown Coins Casino Praised for Fast Redemptions

With the sweepstakes casino industry so volatile these days considering both the popularity of the sector and individual state efforts to quash it, Gambling911.com looks at both the positive and the negative reviews coming in for all brands.
VGW Launches New Chumba Casino iOS App

VGW Launches New Chumba Casino iOS App

VGW is pleased to announce Chumba Casino – the premier online social casino experience in the U.S. – has launched a new iOS app in the Apple App Store, giving players the brand’s full experience in a modern, state of the art native app.
Chumba Casino to Remain in Oklahoma Following Sweepstakes Casino Ban, Introduces Chumba Spins

Chumba Casino to Remain in Oklahoma Following Sweepstakes Casino Ban, Introduces Chumba Spins

Oklahoma's sweepstakes casino ban went into effect Sunday November 1.
Revisiting the So-Called 'Winna.com Casino Scam'

Revisiting the So-Called 'Winna.com Casino Scam'

The most recent TrustPilot reviews of Winna.com are especially head scratching. All are one star interspersed with a few five star reviews that tend to lack in substance.