Colts vs. Steelers Anytime Touchdown Prop Bets: Jonathan Taylor, Jaylen Warren, Tyler Warren

Submitted by C Costigan on

Written by :

C Costigan

Published on :

Anytime and first touchdown scorer prop bets are available for Sunday's game between the Indianapolis Colts and Pittsburgh Steelers, one of the most wagered on matches of the day thus far.  All prop bets and odds courtesy of BetUS, now celebrating 31 years in business. 

KICKOFF260

The Colts and Steelers are meeting for the fourth consecutive season and the fifth time in six years ... Indy has won two straight since snapping a seven-game losing streak in the series. Pittsburgh is 17-5 against the Colts since the franchise moved to Indy in 1984, a mark that includes playoff matchups following the 1995 and 1996 seasons. ... The Steelers have won all five postseason games between these franchises that were among the AFC's elite teams during the first decade of the 21st Century. ... Indy and Pittsburgh were two of the three teams that switched from the NFL to the AFC as part of the 1970 AFL-NFL merger. 

Jonathan Taylor rushed 12 times for 153 yards and two touchdowns in a Week 8 win over the Titans, adding 21 receiving yards and a touchdown on two catches.

Taylor leads the NFL in yards rushing (850), TD runs (12) and total TDs (14) all while averaging 5.9 yards per carry. He's hitting game-changing plays seemingly every week. Plus, he needs two TD runs to surpass Hall of Famers, Lenny Moore (63) and Edgerrin James (64) as the franchise's career leader. It could happen Sunday.

He comes in priced high as the favorite to score a touchdown in this game at -280. 

Jaylen Warren is closer to even odds (-105). 

Tyler Warren pays $135 for every $100 bet to score a touchdown on Sunday. 

Touchdown Prop Bet - Colts vs. Steelers 

Any Time
First
Last
Jonathan Taylor
-280
+260
+420
Jaylen Warren
-105
+800
+700
Tyler Warren
+135
+800
+1000
DK Metcalf
+140
+1100
+900
Michael Pittman Jr.
+170
+900
+1100
Jonnu Smith
+270
+2000
+1400
Calvin Austin III
+270
+2000
+1400
Alec Pierce
+300
+1600
+1700
Josh Downs
+320
+1600
+1800
Daniel Jones
+330
+1800
+1600
Kenneth Gainwell
+350
+2500
+1700
Darnell Washington
+360
+2700
+1500
Pat Freiermuth
+410
+2700
+2000
Indianapolis Defense
+600
+3500
+2700
Ameer Abdullah
+700
+4500
+2200
Roman Wilson
+700
+4000
+3000
Pittsburgh Defense
+750
+4500
+3500
Mo Alie-Cox
+1000
+6500
+3500
Ben Skowronek
+1100
+10000
+4000
Connor Heyward
+1200
+10000
+4000
Adonai Mitchell
+1300
+8000
+5000
Drew Ogletree
+1500
+8000
+6000
Ashton Dulin
+1500
+10000
+5500
Will Mallory
+1500
+8000
+6000
Tyler Goodson
+1600
+10000
+5500
DJ Giddens
+1600
+10000
+5500
Kaleb Johnson
+1800
+10000
+7000
Aaron Rodgers
+1800
+10000
+6500
Ke'Shawn Williams
+3500
+10000
+10000

- Don Shapiro, Gambling911.com 

Related Content

Gambling911.com News

Live Gambling News, Top Trending: Updates 24/7 - Wednesday May 13, 2026

Live News: Northwest Indiana Sports Betting Bust - Missouri Gambling Bust - Primary Odds - Tottenham Relegation
Michael Campbell

Hammond Indiana Alleged 'Enforcer' in Sports Betting Ring Reportedy Hobnobbed With Elected Officials

Alleged enforcer in Northwestern Indiana sports betting bust appears in photographs with top regional elected officials including a Region police chief and recent sheriff's candidate as well as top labor union officials.
Connor McDavid and Auston Matthews

Could Connor McDavid and Auston Matthews Both End Up With San Jose Sharks? Latest Odds

There are pics all over the internet of Conor McDavid and Auston Matthews at an Edmonton bar over the weekend, which has led to BetOnline posting odds asking whether these two will play on the same team next year.
Gambling911.com News

Live Gambling News, Top Trending: Updates 24/7 - Tuesday May 12, 2026

Live News: Primary Odds - KalshiEx LLC v. Schuler - LeBron James - Keir Starmer - Louisiana - Nebraska - West Virginia - Chimaev - UFC 328