Gaming Attorney Daniel Wallach Talks Massachusetts Superior Court Judge 'Preliminary Views' Regarding Kalshi

Submitted by Gilbert Horowitz on

Written by :

Gilbert Horowitz

Published on :

Kalshi

Massachusetts Superior Court Judge Christopher Barry-Smith provided his "preliminary views" as to the likely scope of the preliminary injunction against the prediction market Kalshi.

In September 2025, Massachusetts Attorney General Andrea Joy Campbell filed a lawsuit in state court against Kalshi, which claims that the company was essentially operating illegal sports wagering by offering sports-related event contracts without a Massachusetts sports betting license.

Kalshi, which claims it does not offer a gambling product, argued the case should be heard in federal court on the grounds that its products are regulated under the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) and supervised by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) — and thus federal law preempts state gambling rules.  That attempt to move to a federal venue was rejected. 

Wallach (pictured above) offered this assessment via his X page:

1) Given Kalshi's "nationwide business," Kalshi must use "technological controls" to ensure that sports event contracts are not offered "directly or indirectly" to persons in Massachusetts. (Goes considerably further than the residency bar agreed to by Crypto in the Nevada case). This likely means that geolocation technology must be used.

2) Implementation of these "technological controls" within 30 days, not the 90 requested by Kalshi (which has had months to prepare for this inevitability -- see CFTC's 9/30/25 Notice).

3) Notice to Massachusetts users of this ban need only be provided "in response to a user's attempt to place a bet/contract."

4) Injunction is "forward-looking" only as to future contracts -- with one key exception:

- As to existing sports event contracts, "increasing the amount of an existing bet/contract is the equivalent of placing a new bet/contract and should not be permitted." (By contrast, selling an existing position will be allowed by the court)

5) Deadline for the parties to submit a proposed preliminary injunction order is February 4, 2026.

6) Court will promptly hold another hearing if parties cannot agree on the scope of the PI.

7) Court anticipates deciding Kalshi's emergency request for a stay of the injunction pending appeal on the same timeline.

8) Looks like there will be a decision on the stay motion within the next 2-3 weeks.

  • Gilbert Horowitz, Gambling911.com 

Related Content

Chanced Sweepstakes Casino Returns to Illinois After Being Ordered to Leave

Chanced Sweepstakes Casino Returns to Illinois After Being Ordered to Leave

This appears to be part of a broader trend in which sweepstakes casino companies are entering the digital trading-card market after facing regulatory pressure.
BetMGM Now Offers First Quarter Injury Protection to Gamblers

BetMGM Now Offers First Quarter Injury Protection to Gamblers

If a player leaves the game in the first quarter due to injury, eligible straight wagers may be canceled and the stake returned in cash.
Leicester City Dumps BC.Game Sponsorship Following Porn Star Controversy

Leicester City Dumps BC.Game Sponsorship Following Porn Star Controversy

Russian porn star Eva Elfi, who starred in "Petite HD Porn 28: Too Naughty to Say No", was brought on as BC.Game ambassador earlier this month.
Sweepstakes Casino Review - Crown Coins Casino Praised for Fast Redemptions

Sweepstakes Casino Review - Crown Coins Casino Praised for Fast Redemptions

With the sweepstakes casino industry so volatile these days considering both the popularity of the sector and individual state efforts to quash it, Gambling911.com looks at both the positive and the negative reviews coming in for all brands.