Case Against Online Poker Sites Weak Says I. Nelson Rose

Written by:
C Costigan
Published on:
May/12/2011
Case Against Online Poker Sites

Noted gambling industry attorney I. Nelson Rose breaks down the case against three online poker rooms indicted on April 15:  PokerStars, Full Tilt Poker and UB.com. 

Nelson made his assertions last week on Casino City.com.  It’s a most interesting read. 

Gambling911.com will break down Rose’s points in an easy-to-read format.

The UIGEA is an enforcement tool that only applies to money taken in by the online poker room.  In other words, nobody is going to be charged with simple violation of the Unlawful Internet Gaming Enforcement Act (UIGEA). 

“It requires there be a violation of some other federal or state anti-gambling law,” Rose explains.

In this case, prosecutors charged the defendants with bank fraud and money laundering.

But here is an interesting irony.   Rose suggests that the defendants technically did not commit bank fraud being that such a charge requires there to be a victim.

“The bank fraud statute requires a scheme to either ‘defraud a financial institution’ or to obtain any money owned or held by the bank. The second one won’t work. Lower courts have said the law was designed to protect the integrity of the banking system. But, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that part of the statute means what it says: prosecutors have to show the victim lost money. Here, the banks were supposedly tricked into making millions of dollars. Talk about a victimless crime.”

He adds:  “So, the DoJ is left with having to show that banks were “defrauded.” Again, there will be an issue of what exactly did the banks lose?

“As of June 1, 2010, there are regulations the banks have to follow. But, almost all the events took place prior to that; and, the final regulations do not provide for fines.”

Rose also points to the repeated use of the word “fraud” in the indictments, suggesting that the usage is a means of making it appear to players that online gambling sites cannot be trusted.

The most damning piece of information contained within the indictment, most experts including Rose agree, stems from the allegations that the online poker companies paid off a small Utah bank to apply the gambling transactions. 

“The indictment sets forth facts that would seem to call for a count of bribery, if true. Some of the defendants paid a small Utah bank $10 million to buy 30% of the bank, so the bank would transact online poker payments that the bank was reluctant to do. An officer and part-owner allegedly asked for, and received, $20,000. The indictment is careful to call this payoff a ‘bonus’ rather than a bribe. The banker was charged with conspiracy and being part of the other activities constituting crimes. This avoids the question of who exactly was the victim, since it was the banker who solicited the payment. It also gets around the problem of whether a briber and bribee can also be charged with being coconspirators.”

In closing, Rose states that the seized monies in this case could belong to players, not the online poker rooms – at least a portion of it – and that the US Attorney’s office has no right holding onto it

None of those charged will stand trial, Rose predicts.  They will settle out of court, paying large sums of money and perhaps serving nominal jail sentences. 

- Christopher Costigan, Gambling911.com Publisher

Gambling News

Unikrn Unveils Virtual Betting, Live Streaming Products

Unikrn Unveils Virtual Betting, Live Streaming Products

One of the leaders in eSports betting, Unikrn, has announced the release of a virtual wagering platform and a live streaming product.

West Virginia Sports Betting Falls Into the Red, New Unikrn Betting Platforms Unveiled

West Virginia Sports Betting Falls Into the Red, New Unikrn Betting Platforms Unveiled

To date, one year after the US Supreme Court reversed decades of prohibition of sports wagering, West Virginia's industry is in the red.  The Mountaineer State was among the first to dive in.

Louisiana Sports Betting Effort Marches Forward After Removal of 'Poison Pill'

Louisiana Sports Betting Effort Marches Forward After Removal of 'Poison Pill'

A proposal to legalize sports betting in Louisiana edged forward in the Legislature, winning the backing Tuesday of a committee packed with several anti-gambling lawmakers who unsuccessfully sought to derail the measure.

Sports Betting Forums: Top Discussions

We tap into the hottest discussions on the sports betting forums and social media.  Hot now: Vegas Sports Handicapper Gets Banned From Sportsbooks and Probation, Disney Takes Stake in Draftkings

Sports Handicapper Banned From Sportsbooks for Three Years, Sentenced to Probation

Sports Handicapper Banned From Sportsbooks for Three Years, Sentenced to Probation

A well-known sports handicapper with a platform on ESPN has been sentenced to three years probation.

 

Syndicate