American Idol Performances (May 13)

Carrie Stroup here with your Gambling911.com American Idol performance update for May 13, 2008 and let me tell you something folks, the three remaining Idols started off fantastic.

David Archuleta did Billy Joel.  Syesha Mercado did Alicia Keys.  And David Cook....Roberta Flack's "The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face"?  Yeah, you read that one right.

All were good. David Cook was probably the most original though Randy Jackson - who did not choose the song (it was Simon's choice) - said he had wished Simon didn't pick such an old number.  I loved it!  This kid can sing anything.

And Syesha.  Nobody can compare to Alicia Keys but Syesha looked gorgeous and sang it well. 

Archuleta has that incredible voice that makes this girl's heart melt even though I feel like a friggin' senior citizen watching this kid. 

Okay....but a Chris Brown song?  That was David Archuleta's second choice.  I have one thing to say: Where's Daddy Dearest?

A little disappointing.  Simon called it a chihuahua trying to be a tiger.  A little bit awkward. 

Syesha did "Fever".  Hot number and again she looked fantastic.  Randy thought she sang it fantastic but Paula thought it was not the best choice and Simon felt she might regret this decision and called it "quite a lame cabaret performance". 

David Cook did Switchfoot.  Sounded great.  The judges felt it was okay, nothing spectacular.  I agree with Paula though that it got really good just as it was over.

David Archuleta was doing "Longer" by Daniel Fogelberg. 

Syesha did a number from a movie about penguins and I've never seen Paula so critical...but she does have a point.  I think it will be David vs. David next week.

David Cook did Aerosmith, which was the kiss of death for Michael Johns.  Paula loved it.  Randy didn't but Simon said he won the night.

Bet on American Idol here Finals odds up Thursday.

----

Carrie Stroup, Gambling911.com

Originally published May 13, 2008 9:26 pm EST